Reesor's Pies & Cookies

We are famous for our pies and cookies! Reesor’s pies are loaded with fruit, and they look and taste homemade. You can see and smell pies and cookies baked daily at our Town Market and our Farm Market. Want to bake a pie at home? Look in our freezer section for pies and cookies you can take home, keep in your freezer and bake off when you need them.

What people say about our pies:

“I love Reesor’s pies.”

“We came from downtown Toronto to get this pie.”

“The pie was awesome.”

“Your pies are the best!”

"Best apple pie ever! So yummy! Especially the apple crumble!"

Your Pie Order “Hotline"

We make a variety of pies every day or you can phone ahead 24 hours and we will bake whichever fruit pies you want and we'll make them specially for you.

(905) 640-2270 at our Town Market in Stouffville

(905) 640-4568 at our seasonal Farm Market in Markham (June-October)

Reesor's Own Signature Pies

Butter Tarts—Our scrumptious butter tarts are made locally at a family run bakery.

• Classic

• Raisin

• Pecan

Crisps

• Apple Crisp

• Bumbleberry Crisp

Reesor's Cookies, Cakes & Squares

All of our cookies and cakes are made from scratch by our bakers in Stouffville. You might smell them baking as you enter our town and farm markets.  Our soft and chewy Molasses Crinkles have been our most popular cookie for decades, but each of our cookies have their own unique flavour and devotees! If you like your cookies warm and on demand at home, you can buy packages of our most popular cookies frozen to bake at home. 

Reesor's Own Signature Cookies

• Molasses Crinkles

• Oatmeal Raisin

• Chewy Oatmeal Chocolate Chip

• Classic Chocolate Chip

• Double Chocolate

• Double Chocolate Cranberry

• Nature’s Crunch

• Oat My Goodness

• Amaretti (gluten free)

• Gluten Free Molasses Crinkles

Reesor's Own Signature Cakes & Squares

Our scrumptious squares and cakes are made from our own recipes and are available only at Reesor's Market & Bakery. A selection of squares are also available at Reesor’s Farm Market from June to October.

We bake some of our squares and cakes according to the seasons and special events. Please stop in and discover your new favourite Reesor's baked item or phone 905-640-2270 to inquire if a particular kind of cake is currently available.  

Visit us around Mother’s Day, Father’s Day, Valentine’s Day, Easter and Christmas to see what delicious special layer cake is featured.

• Chocolate Fudge Layer Cake

• Chocolate Raspberry Layer Cake

• Chocolate Almond Brownies (GF)

• Carrot Layer Cake

• Lemon Layer Cake

• Vanilla Buttercream Layer Cake

• Brownies

• Date Squares

• Pumpkin Squares

• Morning Maple Blueberry Loaves

• Pumpkin Loaves

• Tea Biscuits

• Rhubarb Coffee Cake

• Fran’s Coffee Cake

At Valentine's Day, Easter and Christmas we roll out our seasonal cookies and squares for your home and office parties. We bake with the same ingredients you use at home, so our cookies taste homemade! Check out our convenient Christmas cookie trays during December--there's something for everyone.

Here are just a few of our seasonal offerings:

• Nanaimo Bars

• Lemon Bars

• Chocolate Crinkles

• Shortbread

• Gluten Free Shortbread

• Valentine Sugar Cookie

• Mincemeat Tarts